The Art of Intimate Sorrow

An essay for Sad Dads or people who love Sad Dads.

I went to the Greek Theater last Friday night to see Brittany Howard. It was the first time I’d been there since the spring of last year when I went to see The National for what I hoped would be a cathartic and closure-filled experience about my father’s death underneath a dark, cloudy EL AY sky. It worked—just not the way I expected it to.

Brittany Howard is one of the most seismically talented people on our planet, but I drifted a bit during her show and thought about what has transpired since that night and how I have navigated some of the lingering resentments in my life. The Greek is a good spot for tracking spiritual inventory.

The essay below was written a couple of weeks after I saw The National that night. It has links to other TSB stories that are still paywalled.

We also don’t want to exclude anyone, so if the cost is prohibitive or you wish to send TSB to someone you love, contact me. We’ll happily pass along a free annual subscription to those who need it most.

We can offer free subscriptions as long as we continue to grow. Grab a paid subscription today if you’d like to be a part of that growth—spiritually and otherwise. Thanks and enjoy the show.

---

I’ll Get Funny Again

Originally published June 13, 2023

On January 29th, a little more than two weeks after my father died, I bought tickets to see The National at the Greek Theater. I was still in the early opening curtains of what I assumed was grief, so I was convinced the universe had put the band on tour this year, the year I'd reconnected to their music, specifically, the song "Start a War," a track off their 2007 album The Boxer. It was the song I chose to listen to on repeat during the last night with him in the hospital, the one I hoped would give that moment its proper cinematic end. Several times, I put the phone on his shoulder and played him the song as he labored through his final morphine-filled moments, but he did not stir.

So between January 29th and their concert date on May 31st, I'd allotted myself the time to fully mourn as best I could, even though I wasn't sure what that mourning would look like. At what point would I feel the loss, and how much would it weigh?

But now, the universe has provided a roadmap. I would head to the Greek on May 31st, and The National would play "Start a War," it would echo across the dusty orange hills of Griffith Park as an apparition of my smiling father hovered next to me. "We're okay, son," he'd say. And, poof, all my resentments would be swept away with the rest of the ashes. 

This would be my second time seeing The National. I saw them in 2010 at Beacon Theatre, but I remember very little of the show because I began to fall asleep halfway through it. This was a period, too, when I considered myself a true fan of the band—The Boxer was an album I ascribed significant meaning to for a period of my life, but I can't remember exactly why.

But between 2007 and that night at the Beacon, I became cynical and bored by their act. The twinkly drone of their songs wasn't hitting me anymore, especially live. When I would settle into a familiar melody of a song I used to love, say, “Apartment Story" or “Mistaken for Strangers,” Matt Berninger's droopy vocalizing began to sound like it was being pumped through a stereo from inside a burning building: a slow-motion dropping of octaves, followed by a series of warps and pops.

The only time I perked up was during "Mr. November," as he snaked through the crowd with his 9,000-foot microphone cord, assuring the audience, one by one, that he won't fuck us over. It felt like a rock show for that brief moment, but my main takeaway from their performance was that I completely understood why people hated their band. 

But a couple of Wednesdays ago, I was ready to have my mind changed and close the loop on my complicated relationship with my father. It was a good start: peak springtime in Los Angeles, full of jacarandas and a late hazy sunset. Plus, I ran into some friends. My buddy Albin was there, cool as ever. I also bumped into my friend Peter, who I'd primarily known from another men's 12-step group over Zoom. Good times. Then I saw Eddie from my favorite Al-Anon meeting, who I hadn't seen in a long time.

Seeing Eddie, in particular, was a good omen for me—he was a vital force in my Al-Anon group and had some very poignant and helpful shares I clung to over the years, mainly when he talked about the death of his own father. One day, he wore his dad's old shoes to a meeting, which I found incredibly healing. Because Eddie had an important-looking lanyard around his neck, he could stand directly behind the mixing board. My seats were on the balcony, but I chose to stick close to him instead. The lights went down, and a piano clinked: "Once Upon a Poolside," a song off their new album I hadn't listened to, started the show. The song was pretty and glum, as usual. I turned to Eddie and patted him on the back. "It's good to see you, man," I said. Off we went.

*****

So why "Start a War"? Why did I choose that song to be the one that would remind me of my father until the day I also die?

It's probably not about a complicated father-son relationship but most likely one about a tempestuous and failing romantic one, which is what accounts for the subjects of most of their songs.

And another reason why it's such an odd choice—he'd hate the song. To be fair to The National, his musical taste was frustratingly inane. One of his favorite records was the Mama Mia! movie soundtrack, which he'd listen to at high volume on his way to an early tee time at his shitty country club. ("That Cheryl [sic] Streep can really sing!") 

I'd chosen this song for both of us because I considered our relationship a war throughout most of my life—our communication was constantly breaking down, prolonging conflicts more than necessary. But the war that comes to mind is make-believe, perpetrated by little green army men with bazookas and rifles all pointed at nothing. This was our war: imaginary, childlike, and cheap. 

The line from the song that gets me every time, the one I've been singing to myself in every quiet moment since he died, goes like this: 

Whatever went away, I'll get it over again, I'll get money, and I'll get funny again.

I always thought that if I became financially secure enough to buy him dinner or pay for my own golf shoes—whatever made him proudest—we'd be at peace. But whenever I had a brief windfall, it, too, came freighted with more of his undermining concerns–401k suggestions or reminders that I should set enough side more for taxes, or Roth IRAs, always with the goddamn Roth IRAs. 

And I'd respond with high-minded petulance and defiance, draining my bank account by making an idiotic purchase, usually an ugly expensive piece of furniture, or an impromptu vacation to some bizarre place just to go broke on purpose, to show him who's boss. Take that, Dad. 

*****

A few weeks ago, Amanda Petrusich of The New Yorker wrote what will most likely be the definitive profile of The National — “The Sad Dads of The National,” a headline perfect enough for both The New Yorker and ClickHole. She describes The National's particular brand of melancholy as a study in micro-grief—"the slow accumulation of ordinary losses."

"Maybe there's a person you once loved but lost touch with. A friend who moved to a new town. An apple tree that stood outside your bedroom window leveled to make way for broadband cable. An old dog. A former colleague. We are always losing, or leaving, or being left, in ways both minor and vast."

In the story’s final, most solemn section, Petrusich reveals her proximity to a recent heavy loss—her husband died a few months ago, and she's still destabilized by it. But even in those traumatic and overwhelming circumstances, writing about The National was an ideal assignment.  

"I'd always responded to the band's nervous articulations of heartbreak and yearning, but now they felt heavier, truer, and more comforting. Sadness can sometimes feel like an aesthetic choice, fodder for memes and T-shirts that say things like "Too Bad So Sad" or "Just Another Worst Day of My Life." Compounding pessimism can feel like the only way to express compassion, especially online. That's not the kind of sad I was. The National's music speaks to a more intimate, nonperformative sorrow."

When I read that, I immediately questioned whether my sorrow was performative, one that I'm using to manipulate readers (you) because I know it's a shortcut for me to achieve a brief sense of connection to an outer realm of humans that I'd otherwise ignore or never fully admit that I needed.

I also have this flawed, superficial system for determining whether a newsletter works or is a total flop solely based on the number of complimentary emails or financial donations I receive before 7 a.m. It makes for some anxious and adrenaline-filled mornings, but it's more of a testament to my newfound seriousness about my writing than the short-lived thrills I associated with old-school blogging.

But I'm even more attuned to the results when I write about my father. If I got crickets, I feel the failure more intensely than I would otherwise because then I'm stuck with the memory of him leaving a crazed voicemail message about how ashamed he was of what I wrote, which was a common occurrence back in my Gawker days, especially towards the beginning of 2013 when I was high or on the verge of getting high every single waking moment. 

*****

I am still jolted by the passage of time, as in: the time between his dementia and death was a slow, loopy, arduous five years. Still, in the five months since his death, I constantly forget that he's not coming back. But now I have this easy recall of random and inconsequential parts of his existence: the sounds of his feet on the rug as he entered our old family room in Ambler; the frustrated sigh that came from inside his whole body as he pushed coat hangers around in the closet on a cold, snowy morning. Ordinary losses I'd accumulated and long forgotten are now presented as core memories.

By the time the encore set began, I'd conceded that The National would not play "Start A War" for me. I am sober enough to know that Higher Powers are not our own personal DJs. It would have been nice, but instead, I eased into how okay everything was—how good my father and I are now.

As the encore songs wound down, my feet and hips started to hurt in that real old-man way—first at any concert I've attended. I wanted to leave early, but there would be no time saved in doing so. Plus, I wanted to talk to Eddie more, and I figured we'd have a good amount of time to do that as everyone dizzily shuffled to the exits. 

The National closed with a song from 2010’s High Violet, "Vanderlyle Crybaby Geeks," a crowd favorite. Berninger used a microphone to orchestrate the rest of the audience in a sing-a-long. 

Oh, the water’s a rising

There's still no surprise you

Vanderlyle crybaby cry

Man, it's all been forgiven

Swans are a-swimmin'.'

All the very best of us

String ourselves up for love

Everyone sang, arms raised, exultantly swaying, as if they were waiting for the song forever, one that was played just for them.

LISTEN TO SEVERAL SAD-DAD SONGS ON TSB’S PLAYLIST

---

MORE GRIEF:

---

ZOOM MEETING SCHEDULE

Monday: 5:30 p.m. PT/8:30 ET

Wednesday: 10 a.m. PT/1 p.m. ET

Thursday: 10 a.m. PT/1 p.m. ET (Women and non-binary meeting.)

Friday: 10 a.m. PT/1 p.m. ET

Saturday: Mental Health Focus (Peer support for bipolar/anxiety/depression) 9:30 a.m. PT/12:30 p.m. ET

Sunday: (Mental Health and Sobriety Support Group.) 1:00 p.m PT/4 p.m. ET

*****

If you don't feel comfortable calling yourself an "alcoholic," that's fine. If you have issues with sex, food, drugs, codependency, love, loneliness, and/or depression, come on in. Newcomers are especially welcome.

FORMAT: CROSSTALK, TOPIC MEETING

We're there for an hour, sometimes more. We'd love to have you.

Meeting ID: 874 2568 6609

PASSWORD TO ZOOM: nickfoles

Need more info?: ajd@thesmallbow.com

---

This is The Small Bow newsletter. It is mainly written and edited by A.J. Daulerio. And Edith Zimmerman always illustrates it. We send it out every Tuesday and Friday.

You can also get a Sunday issue for $8 a month or $60 annually. The Sunday issue is a recovery bonanza full of gratitude lists, a study guide to my daily recovery routines, a poem I like, the TSB Spotify playlist, and more exclusive essays. You also get commenting privileges!

Other ways you can help:

BUY A COFFEE MUG FOR YOUR BOOKS

TSB merch is a good thing. [STORE]

or you can

or you can give a

that goes toward the production of the podcast.

Everything helps.

---

A POEM ON THE WAY OUT:

Titanic

by David R. Slavitt

*********

Who does not love the Titanic?
If they sold passage tomorrow for that same crossing,
who would not buy?

To go down... We all go down, mostly
alone. But with crowds of people, friends, servants,
well fed, with music, with lights! Ah!

And the world, shocked, mourns, as it ought to do
and almost never does. There will be the books and movies
to remind our grandchildren who we were
and how we died, and give them a good cry.

Not so bad, after all. The cold
water is anaesthetic and very quick.
The cries on all sides must be a comfort.

We all go: only a few, first-class.

— “The Writer’s Almanac”

---

---